+- RCTgo Forums (https://forums.rctgo.com)
+-- Forum: Everything Else (https://forums.rctgo.com/forum-19.html)
+--- Forum: Contests (https://forums.rctgo.com/forum-137.html)
+---- Forum: Build It! (on hiatus) (https://forums.rctgo.com/forum-25.html)
+---- Thread: Vote for your favorite track! Round 177 (/thread-19478.html)
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 177 - Vert - Aug 23, 2014
I voted for Punica, it looks awesome, way better than The Machine.
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 177 - Chimalion - Aug 23, 2014
W0W, I STILL CAN'T DECIDE ON WHICH ONE:
Here is a list of how it's going.
3. X-Flight
Layout: 7/10
Close to the original one at SFGAm.
Supports: 1/10
No custom supports, that's needed for a Build-It Winner.
Color Scheme: 8/10
The Red Shade could have been a lighter red.
Theming: 0/10
You have no theming that looks like the real one, sorry
Pics: 2/10
You only have 2 pics....
Foliage: 0/10
None.
Final Grade:
14/100 (F)
Wait at least two weeks for better theming, sorry.
2. Twisted Twilight
Layout: 8/10
Very Unique! I love it!
Supports: 7/10
Custom, and looks OK. Could have been done better, but looks good how it is at the moment
Color Scheme: 6/10
I wouldn't say you nailed it, but for the Sci-Fi theme (Is that the theme?) looks fine
Theming: 9/10
I love the building! A indoor ride of this type is unique!
Pics: 6/10
Could have added more pics, but whatever
Foliage: No Grade
This has no grade, because you don't need foliage for Sci-Fi coasters
Overall Grade:
84/100 (B)
Nice job overall!
1. The Machine
Layout: 9/10
For a inverter, you nailed it!
Supports: 8/10
Love them, but a couple of them are unrealistic.
Color Scheme: 8/10
I guess it's good for a desert coaster
Theming: 9/10
I love the theming! Looks so cool
Pics: 7/10
Nice pics, they show alot of the coaster
Foliage: Also No Grade
This coaster doesn't have to have foliage either, and that's perfectly fine!
Overall Grade:
95/100
This looks really good
1. Punica
Layout 10/10 typical B&M Inverted
Realism of coaster to its manufacturer 10/10 can easily see is B&M
supports 10/10 perf
color scheme 9/10 I like having a shade of green on here better
theming 9/10 Generic so cool
Realism in scenery 10/10
pics/pov 5/5
foilage 14.5/15. Could have more ground shrubbery
Do i wanna ride? 10/10 Yes! Of course!
95.100
Nicely done and you're actually quite good at building coasters!
STILL TIED BETWEEN MACHINE AND PUNICA
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 177 - richardye1 - Aug 23, 2014
the supports on the machine was a bit unrealistic tbh.
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 177 - Chimalion - Aug 23, 2014
WAIT Richard, you are right! Most of them are UN(Typo
)-realistic and there are better sets to use for a B&M coaster! I'm voting Punica
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 177 - rccoa coasters - Aug 23, 2014
(Aug 22, 2014, 11:09 PM)LetsPlaySumJames Wrote:I completely understand, and, respect your comment!(Aug 22, 2014, 05:36 PM)rccoa coasters Wrote: Three B&M's. Really?... Really???Really? I don't know what's the problem with people having the same coaster type? I don't think people should be judged on what coaster type they used. It's like picking the underdog In a sports game in which you don't care for both teams. You vote for what you like. Now if you preferred the no limits ride I don't object or anything. But if you think just cause people use a coaster type that other people use means that their coaster isn't good, I don't think you are a good voter. But this is just for fun so don't take me too seriously
Twisted Twilight gets my vote!
-James
But I just have lots of frustration because for a while all that has been in build it are B&M's. I think every coaster in the competition is great and has well deserved a spot in build it! Again, I just want to see a little more change. Thanks for your comment, because I think it really helped me get across what I was trying to say!
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 177 - Slurpee_Man - Aug 24, 2014
I voted Machine
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 177 - Cheleste - Aug 24, 2014
Machine and Punica are both nice, could be close between them.
The other's need alot of practice, currently both are basic, simple, boring.
I cant understand why people dont take look at past build-it winners first!
If i seen a great creation and have only a naked one by myself, than i should think twice before i enter it.
And if i only want to show people my work to become feedback, than open up a thread for it.
A [WIP]-Thread is a good thing to show people your work and become feedback. And than, after finishing it you can allways enter the finished deisgn into build it.
But half finished entries are boring and horrible to look at!
In the end "Punica" got the vote from me, but "Machine" is on the same level.
Both would deserves the win!
Lg Cheleste
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 177 - aecrouch2016 - Aug 25, 2014
When an entry for the build it competition doesn't have any scenery behind I don't understand (with all do respect). I've seen this a couple of times now.
Making a theme helps so much to draws (well at least in my opinion...meant with kindness) more attention. I voted for "Punica" for many different reasons. The over all design, the detailed finishing touches. The color scheme and the coaster itself. I am not ready to enter this competition yet. Because I have trouble coming up with a theme so I have more to learn. I like seeing the different entries during the competition. Because my draw drops and usually says how did they do that and enter in time for the competition. So I've been watching tutorials on how to do things. And may be in the near future I will enter this. And I all ways welcome feedback with my designs (good and bad). How can you learn how you are doing and what you need to work on to get better if you don't.
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 177 - SUPER MOOSE93 - Aug 25, 2014
struggling to make a decision for this round.
Twisted twilight
the track looks like it has a good layout.... but i cant tell because you havent shown it all. a POV would have been appreciated, or at least a full overview of the track. not to sure why all the supports join together into the same footers, looks a bit messy.
as for the scenery, i dont really need to say much. a big box and the default station... i understand NL is more for creating a proper coaster but from videos i have seen, you can still do a lot with scenery
X flight
yeah... im not a fan of recreations, even less so when there is no effort put into it. its not hard to copy a track.
next time you enter, at least do something with the scenery. waste of an entry space if you ask me
Machine
the layout looks very good, nice interaction with the scenery that is there. the scenery looks nice but could do with a few more buildings, looks a bit bare in a few places. again, a POV would have been nice.
punica
that looks great. scenery is amazing and the layout was nice. the ride is a little too fast paced for a family coaster though (seems a bit too fast for a normal coaster really).
at this rate, its a close match between punica and machine. if we could get a POV for machine, i may be swayed that direction is the ride looks nice and smooth
side note: really wish justin would review the entries before putting them up for a vote
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 177 - v1210 - Aug 28, 2014
no comments im just to busy atm with follow ups med patient portal(why does each doctor have a patient portal but they dont go to a single central data source not knowing this i made a medium booboo and now i must sit in the doctors offices for a looong time fixin it so....indepth nexr time
punica for the win!