+- RCTgo Forums (https://forums.rctgo.com)
+-- Forum: Everything Else (https://forums.rctgo.com/forum-19.html)
+--- Forum: Contests (https://forums.rctgo.com/forum-137.html)
+---- Forum: Build It! (on hiatus) (https://forums.rctgo.com/forum-25.html)
+---- Thread: Vote for your favorite track! Round 170 (/thread-18727.html)
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 170 - v1210 - Jun 17, 2014
Steel Instinct 6.8 out of 10
I like the layout.
NO custom supports ,no theming or scenery and there is only one pic
Siege (a B&M Sitdown) 8.35 out of 10
Very nice island theme! Works well.
Theres no pov i need more screenshots to give a opinion when this close of competition
It looks like a really fun and intense ride. i liked it
Collosus 7.85 out of 10
I cant see as much of the ride as I liked to, but i do see some interesting elements and another fine job.
Now you need to work on filming ,screening and presenting your designs.
Grizzly (a B&M Floorless) 9 out of 10
I like yellow/grey color scheme ,great layout and professional pov presentation maybe rethink bloom
might cause just a touch to much glare
Great Job!!!
while I like the layout of steel instinct for a total package I vote: Grizzly
GREAT ONE
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 170 - IntaminAndrew - Jun 18, 2014
Why does everyone think Steel Instinct has a "great" layout?
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 170 - richardye1 - Jun 18, 2014
(Jun 18, 2014, 05:03 AM)IntaminAndrew Wrote: Why does everyone think Steel Instinct has a "great" layout?i dont like it tbh lol but i think theyre doing it to make him feel better
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 170 - Cobra - Jun 19, 2014
Vote goes to "Grizzly"
First off, i see again 4 entries with stations that looking basic/boring!
A coaster isn't only a track layout with trains on it. If you want athmosphere around it, most of you (me too) should spend more time in things around the coaster (pathways, souvenirs).
I think most of us spend so much love and time only to the layout and custom supporting, but this isn't enough in the future to beeing good.
So we all should learn to build more than normal, boring stations with boring queue-lines, too.
Siege & Grizzly are the only ones that have a chance to win, in fact of the first screens we see.
A picture can say more than 1000 words.
And only one picture isn't a good start for presenting a coaster, so "Steel Instinct" is busted.
My opinion is, that "Steel Instinct" needs way more time to spend on it.
At this time, the layout isn't realistic, no cso's, no foliage, no presentation -> bad entry!
If someone hates me for my opinion, i can deal with it! Why? Because i'm to old for this orange.
"Colossus":
is nothing special against the other two. The name doen't fits to an B&M Flyer, in my opinion.
Colossus reminds me to the Woodie in SFMM or maybe the 10-Inverter at Thorpe Park.
The colors are nothing special, too.
"Siege":
The reason why my vote goes not to it, is that tropical theming needs tropical colors and red with white supports are not tropical to me.
Some of you think the same about "Grizzly", in fact of yellow/grey colors, and maybe Grizzly sounds better to an Woodie. I think Grizzly can fit with both, Steel and Wood ones.
And i dont know why, but i like the yellow/grey combo of it
.From 1-10, here my vote in numbers:
Siege - 8.1
Grizzly - 8.3
Colossus - 6.0
Steel Instinct - 1.5
@Andrew:
Take a look back here, and than you know why people dont say there "real" opion about other ones work. Cheleste was on of this members here, she wrote the truth about the works and what she think, and in the end there were little whiny kids and haters! And why? Because most of the little kids here cant deal with critique.
With that in mind, i think most members, give "positive" Feedback, but think the opposite of it, but they hope, that if they entered build-It, to become more votes, because they were friendly in the past.
I had a long break from RCT3, just buisness. and i took a look to the past build-It threads.
And there i see that most of the time, "real" friends vote for each other, and it doesn't matter how good/bad the entry is/was.
I vote for "...", because he is my schoolfriend/good youtuber, blabla.
So sometimes not the best Designer wins, nope, the one with more friends win. That isn't really fair and clean.
So you have it Andrew, little kids want to have alot of friends in the community to become there votes in the future.
But the funny or ridiculous thng about all these is the fact, that "Build-It" is only a Fun-Competition with RCT!
It's NOT the "Oscar", the "Emmy" or the "Novelprice"!
But some kids here think they are the best of the rest if they won for once.
Sorry for this long message, i'm out.
Soo long, Cobra
(dont take things to serious, the life is to short for it)
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 170 - aecrouch2016 - Jun 19, 2014
There are many good choices in my opinion in this round. Grizzly however, one of my favorites. I like how the peeps were included in the scenery and on the ride when showing the video. Great to hear their reactions. The scenery and attention to detail also caught my eye.
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 170 - v1210 - Jun 20, 2014
true i usually try to encourage naked track entries by picking the best feature but usually its the first or second upload for them and id like to hope they would continue to support our community and even try another entry, while it is quite true about voting ;we are growing in size and diversity and it never hurts to encourage people to feel at home.
GREAT ONE
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 170 - Chimalion - Jun 20, 2014
Finally voted. I voted for Siege!
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 170 - Kaptain2745 - Jun 20, 2014
SIEGE - good design overall. The coaster seems quite long from the photos, which is a good thing, in my book.
GRIZZLY - This is the one I voted for. I liked the overall layout, with the detail of the park around the track.
COLOSSUS - This one looked interesting, but with the track so close together, wondering are there any clashes?
STEEL INSTINCT - Looks like an interesting layout, but not at the level of completeness of the other entries. Also, wondering if that uber-extreme level takes it into the realm of the un-ride-able?
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 170 - KoasterKing205 - Jun 21, 2014
Chim, I have to agree with you on this. In my opinion, Siege is more unique than Grizzly (It's still unique though). Grizzly just looks like a regular B&M Floorless, no offense to you Murph.
So yeah, you can tell above that I'm voting for Siege!
RE: Vote for your favorite track! Round 170 - jcgr997 - Jun 21, 2014
Now THIS round is scary!!! Here's the order.
Least- Steel Instinct- Some rounds like this one, there is a out-of-place ride.
Colossus- There's alot to it! I especially like the supports and scenery.
Favs!!! Siege- I really like this ride!
Grizzly- Interesting coaster!
I'm quite tied between Grizzly and Siege, and in the end Siege wins my vote