+- RCTgo Forums (https://forums.rctgo.com)
+-- Forum: Everything Else (https://forums.rctgo.com/forum-19.html)
+--- Forum: Contests (https://forums.rctgo.com/forum-137.html)
+---- Forum: Build It! (on hiatus) (https://forums.rctgo.com/forum-25.html)
+---- Thread: Vote for your favorite 3 tracks! Round 200 is HERE. (/thread-20693.html)
RE: Vote for your favorite 3 tracks! Round 200 is HERE. - naveisawesome - Jun 15, 2015
Votes go to ta-seti, phantom and whirlwind
RE: Vote for your favorite 3 tracks! Round 200 is HERE. - Slurpee_Man - Jun 18, 2015
Good round, good luck everyone. =)
RE: Vote for your favorite 3 tracks! Round 200 is HERE. - ctg614 - Jun 18, 2015
Totally vote for Halloween for no reason whatsoever . . . lol. :-)
Check out the POV here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BnZ31VhdbeY
RE: Vote for your favorite 3 tracks! Round 200 is HERE. - Junkincoaster - Jun 18, 2015
Underdogs need some support too, right?
I voted Colonial, Barca, and Red Sea Snake. The underdogs.
RE: Vote for your favorite 3 tracks! Round 200 is HERE. - LetsPlaySumJames - Jun 18, 2015
This is a recurring theme on RCTgo. I see in alot of build it's that people vote for underdogs just to vote for underdogs. I appreciate the support for my ride, but I hope you actually voted for your favorite ones.
RE: Vote for your favorite 3 tracks! Round 200 is HERE. - Rudy18 - Jun 18, 2015
Since no one has done a full review of all coasters this round surprisingly, I guess ill do it...
1. Ta-Seti
The only dark ride in this round, it looks very well done and fully themed. The lightning and the interaction of scenery with the ride is what really makes this coaster. Score: 8.0/10
2. Superman-THE 4TH LAW
Not sure what to say about the supports, they look custom due to the flanges and footers, but they seem to a similar look in style to the default supports. Other than that, im not too sure where the "Superman" theme is, the ride seems to be surrounded with generic scenery except for the rocky area (which could have used a bit more variety in rock selection and useage). Score: 5.5/10
3. King Cobra
Although just recently getting into RCT3, you have done a very good job for one of your first CS coasters. Even though this track was originally made for a completely different coaster type in RCT2, it still works fairly well , though maybe a bit too many inversions for this size of a coaster. Your video does not show the scenery however and you only get small glimpses at the scenery through your screenshots. Unfortunately I can not judge based on your experience, but solely on comparison to others in this competition. Score: 6.5/10 (8/10 as one of your first attempts)
4. Phantom
My entry, cant say anything
5. Zilant
The color scheme looks pretty cool, and the layout is pretty good. A good variety of trees were used, although lacking in ground shrubbery. The ground looks well colored, though a bit flat. I dont feel like the station fits with the theme very well, but thats just my opinion. It might just be the colors, but something doesnt feel right with me. Score: 7.5/10
6. Barca
A very nice color scheme on the coaster, and the surrounding scenery looks great, however the coaster layout bothers me. Its layout seems to focus too much on inversions rather than the sensation of flying B&M flyers normally go for. Other than that I see no real problems with it. Score: 7.0/10
7. Crash Bandicoot: The Ride
The surrounding scenery could have used some work, as is typical with most NL coasters. Although some effort was put in, the flat colorless terrain and the lack in tree variety doesn't feel like you are racing through the jungle like Crash Bandicoot. My only problems with the layout are big left turn after the first drop, the turnaround, and the turn before dropping into the tunnel. The large turn seems to detract from the ride experience and take a lot of the intensity away. I think a low incline hammerhead maneuver would have been better suited here. As for the turnaround, I dont know if it is intentional but the angles seem very weird, facing outwards before facing sharply inwards. The turn before the tunnel drop seems to whip you back into the flat track very suddenly, and looks rather painful. Score: 5.0/10
8. Torrent
17 inversions?!? Holy crap! I must commend you on keeping this layout relatively compact for all of those inversions, however the lack of scenery and the intensity this ride would put out detracts from the experience. The ride looks pretty smooth, so it would at least be survivable! Score: 5.5/10
9. Red Sea Snake
This ride looks exactly the same as all of your other coasters, same trees, same station, same scenery. The coaster also appears to be going way too fast for a majority of the ride as well. The ride is lacking ground shrubbery too, along with many other entries
. The supports are pretty good as usual however. Score: 5.5/1010. Avengers Showdown
It must have been very frustrating to build this coaster among all of these buildings! The city looks very well built, and with the only noticable custom scenery being the supports, this does not look all that bad! The ability to fit two dueling flying coasters in that space too is pretty remarkable as well. The supports also being connected solely to buildings is rather unique as well. Score: 6.5/10
11. Colonial
Not too much I can say, no POV or overall screenshots makes it difficult to determine the layout of the ride. The custom supports were done fairly well, wooden custom supports are a pain and must have credit given. The scenery around looks fairly nice, but there's not much else I can say about the coaster. Score: Cant accurately judge
12. Whirlwind
As others have said, this almost looks like its not even from RCT3! Although the scenery is rather generic (you even say so in your description LOL), it is well detailed and is executed very well. The station is nothing too over the top and fits the ride very well. The ride is very smooth and flows pretty well, even though its a bit of a generic layout as well. Score: 8/10
RE: Vote for your favorite 3 tracks! Round 200 is HERE. - rccoa coasters - Jun 18, 2015
^ About my ride not having to much of an overall screenshot, I had tried to upload an overhead shot, but, somehow, it got lost in the process.
I'll post it here tomorrow.
Thanks for the feedback!
RE: Vote for your favorite 3 tracks! Round 200 is HERE. - MrNozem77 - Jun 19, 2015
Indeed great feedback, Rudy18! Also a score of 8.0/10 for 'Ta-Seti'? Wow, thanks a lot!
'Phantom' is pretty impressive as well! The amount of hours and effort put into this ride must have been enormous.
RE: Vote for your favorite 3 tracks! Round 200 is HERE. - Maverick360 - Jun 19, 2015
Thank you Rudy for giving me feedback!
RE: Vote for your favorite 3 tracks! Round 200 is HERE. - Slurpee_Man - Jun 20, 2015
My final scores
Ta-Seti by MrNozem77:
-Really a good darkride portion
-The layout is pleasant and elegant, why no ctr?
- 3/5 Good but not as good as other MrNozem77 rides.
King Cobra by NieSch:
-I've always loved NieSch's creations, this one is no exception
-HOOLP!
-4/5 Great supporting job.
Halloween by (i'm assuming) ctg614:
-Interesting theming, but for crying out loud, it's June
-Love eurofighters.
-2/5 okay, not too shabby.
Phantom by Rudy18 and Terry Inferno:
-Fabulous, an rct2 entry
-Really a great setting and layout.
-4/5 Vote one.
Zilant by Colts18to87td and (some) Max:
-Don't see many Arrow hypers
-Interesting coaster but kind of an odd setting for an Arrow hyper.
-4/5 good but not the norm kind of Arrow hyper.
Barca by LetsPlaySumJames:
-Uhhhh
-I like flying coasters, interesting layout.
-3/5 Nice coaster and yet it looks more like an Inverted layout.
Crash Bandicoot: The Ride by Ian44accordix:
-Meh
-Kind of painful layout.
-2/5 Sorry i'm not a noLimits guy.
Torrent by Maverick360:
-Good one
-Should be real!
-4/5 Very good but HOOLP!
Red Sea Snake by Imagineer Josh (chimalion70005):
-Like Rudy said about all your rides looking the same
-Okay job but not enough kick (not comparable to Vekoma/Arrows)
-3/5 Okay we need to get the collab up and running dude!
Avengers Showdown by nathan8848:
-Fantastic! Seen Age of Ultron yet? I have twice!
-Truly good coaster.
-4/5 whee! vote 2.
Colonial by rccoa coasters:
-Beautiful ride
- Bobsleds rule!
-4/5 vote three.
Whirlwind by Max:
-Nice setting
-relaxed layout
-4/5 too generic
My entry sucks. I'm not gonna win. Oh well.
Swell, Slurpee