A few of my mates didnt like it, a few of them did, i loved it to death.The Ex hated it also.....cmon Johnny Depp is incredible.The first film is great....but its a musical....well Roald Dahl didnt like it.

I haven't seen the new one but I want to. I love the 1st one -would still watch it. When I saw the poster board for this new one I thought it would be a continuance from the 1st on, but I was told otherwise -I still want to see it.

The new one!! Its more faithful to the books and its what Chocolate Factory was meant to be!! Also i loved how it was all dark and stuff!! Love Tim Burton!!

I've resently saw the 2nd one and it was ok, but I don't think it tops the 1st one.

The first one for me

although i must say i like the actor of willy wonka in the first one compared to Johnny Deep but he was okay as well...a bit on the wierd side though...but oi guess Wonka is suposed to be wierd

the first one was more of a musical i thought.

It was more musical. What I liked about Jonny Depp is that he was more of a smart -A$% which was funny.

the old movie is much better then the new one